RANDOM MUSINGS

• •

Declining consumption inequality by SK Ghosh and Falguni Sinha

Interesting article in the Hans India dated 21 July, 2025

  • The Gini coefficient is a statistical measure that represents income or wealth inequality within a population. 
  • Fall from 28.8 (2011-12) to 25.5 (2022-23).
  • Income based estimates puts India at 62 in 2023 in terms of inequality.
  • Conflating of distinctly different measures of inequality.
  • Difference between CONSUMPTION INEQUALITY and INCOME INEQUALITY.
  • Large informal workforce, extensive in-kind transfers, and rapidly expanding welfare architecture
  • Income volatile, underreported, and difficult to capture.
  • Consumption smoother and reflects actual living standards.
  • World Bank’s new indicator: income to consumption Gini coefficient
  • Average is 1.13 across 84 country years
  • India now placed at 12th
  • India’s inequality even when measured in income terms is lower than UK and USA.
  • China consumption is 35, ten points higher.
  • Large scale welfare programs, LPG, rations, electricity, health, direct cash transfer, rural employment in India.
  • Consumption is higher.
  • Inequality estimates are based only on income generation “pre-tax, post replacement national income” which is income before taxes and transfers (except for pensions and unemployment benefits).
  • The non-contributory welfare transfers are ignored leading to a skewing of data regarding the inequalities.